Reviews

Praise for Not In This World

“Jane Stuart writes like a Southern angel, with a voice that sings and beguiles, much like her enigmatic and irresistible character, Paul. Intimate yet sweeping, Paul Carew's story weaves an age-old tale of a black man's domestic servitude with a disarmingly contemporary exploration of sexual gender identity, almost as if 'Transparent' met 'The Help'. The book haunts you and stays with you and breaks your heart. I’m a screenwriter and after reading it I couldn’t stop thinking: this beautiful book has to be made into a movie. My second thought was: I have to write the script.”

— Becky Johnston — Screenwriter, The Prince of Tides, Seven Years in Tibet, The House of Gucci

“Written with such tenderness that it bruises the heart.”

— Parisa Ebrahimi, Vice President and Executive Director at Penguin Random House

“This is very, very good—you will be published. I love Paul and Jane… can’t wait…”

— Tom Maschler — Former Editor in Chief, Publisher at Jonathan Cape; Booker Prize Founder

“Closely-observed, beautifully rendered and deeply affecting, Paul’s story is told with elegance, economy and empathy. Readers, know this: Not in This World is out of this world.”

— Andrew Cohen — Journalist and author of Two Days in June: John F. Kennedy and the 48 Hours That Made History

“Scott Stuart’s sharply drawn, swift-moving scenes are rich with metaphor, like the butterfly fables Paul tells that express his longing for transformation. In some places, the prose swings and dazzles, while in others it’s taut as the rope that hangs Paul’s unfortunate best friend, Moses. Characters aren’t defined or limited by prejudice but are fully human in their hopes, compassion, and grief. In her Author’s Note, Scott Stuart reveals that the story is an imagined life of her own Paul, making the novel a tender homage. ”

— Blue Sky Oct 2026

“Not in This World is a poignant exploration of love and ties between people that defy every one of society’s boundaries. With vivid prose and dialogue so gripping, this novel lingered with me long after I read the last page.”

— Victoria Christopher Murray — Instant New York Times bestselling author of The Personal Librarian

“I actually read the book in a single sitting — fluent, compelling — arresting, insightful and often unique. An extraordinary and powerful character study, almost picaresque, taking place over a lifespan. Filmmakers will love this material.”

— Allan Scott — Producer and Screenwriter, Don’t Look Now, The Preacher’s Wife, The Queen’s Gambit

“Jane Stuart gets right under the skin of Paul and Jane, the two main characters in her remarkable book. With descriptive vigor and dazzling dialogue she tells the poignant love story that unfolds between a gay black man and the white baby placed in his care. A powerful, captivating and brave book. I loved it.”

— Charlotte Mosley - Editor and Author

“Jane Stuart has given us a unique and profound story of survival: out of small-town 1930s Kentucky come a white girl and a queer man of colour joined at the hip. Their need for one another within a homophobic, rigidly racialized society unfurls in Stuart's vivid narrative, sweeping through World War Two, across the Atlantic and back, and into late-1950s Washington, DC. The triumph of their mutual understanding achieved in spite of then-unspeakable barriers stands as a landmark in the annals of American friendship.”

— Emily Bingham - Author of Irrepressible: The Jazz-Age Life of Henrietta Bingham

“ The absolute triumph of this novel lies in its complex, vibrant protagonist. Paul is a gentle, creative soul who finds joy in baking, sewing, tending flowers, and dressing in his mother’s clothes and makeup—all while navigating the harsh, terrifying authority of his preacher father, Elijah. Stuart writes with what reviewers call “descriptive vigor”, capturing the sensory world of the Jim Crow South and tracking Paul’s life as unexpected events tie him to a white child named Jane.”

— GlOSS Book Club founder, Erin Woodward

““Not In This World” is a triumph of character-driven fiction. By grounding complex themes of race, queer identity, and systemic oppression in the specific, sensory details of Paul's inner and domestic life, Stuart and Flowers have created a narrative that feels both historically grounded and timelessly human. It is a novel about the immense cost of survival, and the quiet glory of remaining unbroken."”